Skip to main content

Referees Guidelines for the Stuart Rossiter Trust

White Divider

Notes for the Guidance of Referees

The Trust as a Charity must take all reasonable steps to satisfy itself that the quality and the integrity of the publications which it is supporting are of the highest standard. It is the policy of the Trustees of the Charity not to rely entirely on their own judgment. The Trustees usually appoint two independent referees who report to the Trustees, after taking an independent and objective view of the work. The Trustees appoint a general referee to comment to them on the subject matter that the author is writing about, how well that objective has been satisfied and the way that the work is set out for the reader in terms of clear presentation and comprehensibility, and a special referee who will consider and give guidance on the technical content of the work.

General Referee

Generally speaking, the Trustees retain control of the appointment of the referees, though the general referee is appointed totally at the discretion of the Trustees but with the knowledge of the author.

A general referee will have regard to all the considerations that he himself would apply to writing a book and what he would expect a reader to gain from reading or consulting the work. As a result of such an assessment, the general referee should inform the Trustees what aspects need to be considered by them before deciding whether or not to proceed with publication of the work.

Special Referee

The Trustees generally accept a recommendation from the author as to who might be the best person to be the special referee on the subject-matter of the work. The Trustees may, in some cases, decide to appoint someone of their choice to act as special referee. As the special referee reports to the Trustees, the author may have to accept a degree of criticism so that the quality of the work fulfils the standards set by the Trustees. Good understanding (and perhaps lack of rivalry) between the author and the special referee is highly desirable.

The Trustees need a critique of the proposed work. It may be that facts are actually incorrect, or analysis or deduction needs to conform to the facts or should be better expressed by reference to other material included in the work. Alternative views may need to be expressed in order to state the argument that flows from the propositions in the text. Lists and tables of data may necessitate improvement; additional illustrations, maps, diagrams or charts may also be necessary to help a reader to understand the text or perhaps replace a particular piece of text visually. The special referee should feel able to make critical remarks in a way which we will be accepted by the author in order to ensure that the work will be valued by those who read or consult it.

The special referee should take care to make sure that the author has correctly represented the limitation imposed on the subject matter either because of the lack of historical or other reference material or because the author is a specialist in a specific field and the work is not of a general nature. Particular attention should be paid to the introduction and opening chapter of the work in this regard, to the method and quality of the bibliography, and the quality of the index.


The Trustees take decisions as to the method of production adopted for the proposed work. Nevertheless the Trustees would value recommendations or suggestions from the referees about ways in which the work might best be published to achieve quality standards and their views on the most appropriate market in which the work might sell. 30.05.2011

Latest News


The Rossiter Newsletter – 68

Shropshire Postal Markings by Brian Atkins A detailed study in 146 pages, Shopshire Postal Markings (Third edition) includes the postal markings of the county from 1706 up to c1910. Since the…

The Rossiter Newsletter – 67

The Stuart Rossiter Memorial Lecture will be at 5pm on Wednesday 15 May 2024 at the RPSL, 15 Abchurch Lane, London. EC4N 7BW Simon Martin-Redman FRPSL will be speaking on…

The Rossiter Newsletter – 66

British Long Distance Mail Packets Volume 2 The Harwich Packets 1816-1834, Rates Routes and Ships Out and Home by Colin Tabeart A detailed study of Harwich packets based on original research from newspapers…
Rossiter Trust Newsletter

The Rossiter Trust Newsletter

Get highlights of the most important news delivered to your email inbox.

Red Graphic Divider

Support the Trust

Help the Trust promote research into the history of the postal services and written communication and to support publication in this area of study.

Find out more
Red Graphic Divider